9 Critical DST Implementation Mistakes and Prevention Strategies
Establishing a Deferred Sales Trust (DST) can provide significant tax advantages when selling appreciated assets, but the path is filled with potential pitfalls. DST implementation mistakes can lead to disqualification of the trust, immediate tax liability, penalties, and lost opportunities. Understanding these common errors is essential for anyone considering this sophisticated tax strategy.
This comprehensive guide examines the most frequent DST implementation mistakes and provides practical strategies to avoid them. By learning from others’ missteps, you can ensure your DST structure provides the intended benefits while withstanding potential IRS scrutiny.
Table of Contents
- Mistake #1: Improper Trust Timing and Sequence
- Mistake #2: Insufficient Trust Independence
- Mistake #3: Inadequate Documentation
- Mistake #4: Poor Trustee Selection
- Mistake #5: Inappropriate Investment Policy
- Mistake #6: Installment Note Structure Errors
- Mistake #7: Improper Asset Valuation
- Mistake #8: Security and Collateralization Problems
- Mistake #9: Insufficient Professional Guidance
- Preventative Strategy Framework
- Case Study: DST Implementation Done Right
- FAQs: Avoiding DST Implementation Mistakes
Mistake #1: Improper Trust Timing and Sequence
One of the most devastating DST implementation mistakes involves incorrect timing or sequencing of key events:
The Mistake
- Establishing the trust after a sale is already in progress or after signing a binding sale agreement
- Creating the trust but failing to transfer assets before entering into a sale contract
- Having a prearranged sale to a specific buyer before the trust owns the asset
- Incorrect sequencing of documentation execution
Why It Matters
The IRS requires that the trust genuinely sells the asset—not the original owner. If you’ve already legally obligated yourself to sell to a specific buyer, transferring to a DST won’t work. This DST implementation mistake can result in complete disqualification of the installment sale treatment.
Prevention Strategy
- Establish the DST before any binding sale agreements
- Transfer assets to the trust before negotiating with potential buyers
- Document that the trustee has independent authority to negotiate sale terms
- Ensure no legally binding obligation to sell exists before trust ownership
- Follow a proper documentation sequence with expert guidance
“Timing isn’t just important—it’s everything with DST implementation. A properly structured DST must be established before a sale is legally binding, or the entire tax deferral strategy falls apart.” — Tax Court Memorandum 2018-17
Mistake #2: Insufficient Trust Independence
Another critical area for potential DST implementation mistakes involves inadequate separation between the seller and the trust:
The Mistake
- Excessive seller control over trust operations or investments
- Trustee acting as a mere “rubber stamp” for seller decisions
- Insufficient arm’s-length negotiation of sale terms
- Commingling personal and trust assets
- Improper communication channels between seller and trustee
Why It Matters
For a DST to be valid, the trust must function as a genuinely independent entity. Without proper separation, the IRS may invoke the step-transaction doctrine, treating the arrangement as if the seller directly sold the asset and received the proceeds. This DST implementation mistake essentially negates the entire tax deferral purpose.
Prevention Strategy
- Select a truly independent trustee with relevant expertise
- Establish clear written policies for trust governance
- Document all arm’s-length negotiations with formal communications
- Avoid agreements that give the seller effective control over trust assets
- Maintain strict separation between personal and trust finances
- Create formal channels for all seller-trustee communications
Mistake #3: Inadequate Documentation
Proper documentation is essential to avoid DST implementation mistakes:
The Mistake
- Missing or incomplete trust agreements
- Vague or imprecise installment sale contracts
- Lack of investment policy documentation
- Insufficient evidence of asset transfer to the trust
- Improper or missing corporate records for entity sales
- Inadequate ongoing trust administration records
Why It Matters
In the event of IRS scrutiny, documentation is your primary defense. Without comprehensive, properly executed documents, your DST structure becomes vulnerable to challenge. This DST implementation mistake can be especially problematic several years into the arrangement when reconstructing intentions and decisions becomes difficult.
Prevention Strategy
- Engage specialized legal counsel to draft comprehensive trust documents
- Ensure all agreements clearly reflect the parties’ intentions
- Create detailed investment policy statements
- Maintain meticulous records of asset transfers and trust activities
- Document the business purpose beyond tax deferral
- Implement a systematic record-keeping system for ongoing trust administration
- Conduct regular documentation reviews for completeness
Mistake #4: Poor Trustee Selection
The trustee plays a pivotal role in DST success, making trustee selection a potential area for serious DST implementation mistakes:
The Mistake
- Choosing a trustee without sufficient independence from the seller
- Selecting a trustee with inadequate experience or expertise
- Appointing a trustee with insufficient financial capacity or bonding
- Using a trustee with conflicts of interest
- Selecting a trustee without succession planning
Why It Matters
The trustee must make independent decisions in managing the trust and its assets. A trustee who lacks independence, expertise, or financial stability creates substantial risk for the DST structure. This DST implementation mistake can undermine the entire arrangement’s validity.
Prevention Strategy
- Select a professional, experienced trustee with DST-specific knowledge
- Verify the trustee has no disqualifying relationships with the seller
- Ensure the trustee has adequate financial stability and insurance
- Confirm the trustee has a succession plan for continuity
- Consider institutional trustees for larger transactions
- Document the trustee selection process and rationale
- Create clear trustee guidelines and expectations
Mistake #5: Inappropriate Investment Policy
The trust’s investment approach often contains DST implementation mistakes:
The Mistake
- Overly restrictive investment policies that effectively give the seller control
- Excessively risky investment strategies that jeopardize payment obligations
- Investment approaches misaligned with distribution requirements
- Lack of diversification leading to concentration risk
- Investments with prohibited self-dealing characteristics
Why It Matters
The trust’s investments must balance growth, safety, and liquidity to meet payment obligations. Inappropriate investment strategies can either signal too much seller control or create practical risks to the trust’s sustainability. This DST implementation mistake can threaten both legal compliance and financial performance.
Prevention Strategy
- Develop a formal investment policy statement that balances seller input with trustee independence
- Align investments with installment payment obligations
- Implement appropriate diversification strategies
- Avoid investments in assets or entities related to the seller
- Create a systematic review process for investment performance
- Document all investment policy decisions and rationales
- Engage qualified investment advisors familiar with DST requirements
Mistake #6: Installment Note Structure Errors
The installment note’s terms often contain DST implementation mistakes:
The Mistake
- Unrealistic or uncommercial interest rates
- Payment terms that don’t reflect genuine economic reality
- Note duration that’s unreasonably long or short
- Excessive seller control over payment acceleration or modification
- Inadequate security provisions for the note
- Terms inconsistent with the seller’s financial needs
Why It Matters
The installment note must reflect commercially reasonable terms that would exist between unrelated parties. Artificial or unrealistic terms signal potential tax avoidance rather than legitimate business structuring. This DST implementation mistake is a common focus of IRS scrutiny.
Prevention Strategy
- Structure the note with market-rate interest appropriate for the risk
- Create payment terms that reflect economic reality
- Balance seller needs with commercial reasonableness
- Document the rationale for all note terms
- Compare terms to what would exist between unrelated parties
- Include appropriate security provisions without excessive seller control
- Have the note terms reviewed by specialized tax counsel
Mistake #7: Improper Asset Valuation
Asset valuation problems represent frequent DST implementation mistakes:
The Mistake
- Inadequate or improper asset appraisals
- Using interested parties for valuation
- Inconsistent valuations across different documents
- Failure to document valuation methodology
- Insufficient support for “special use” or discount valuations
- Post-sale price adjustments without proper documentation
Why It Matters
Accurate, defensible asset valuation is essential for establishing the installment sale’s legitimacy. Improper valuations can suggest disguised gifts, artificially engineered tax benefits, or other non-economic motivations. This DST implementation mistake creates significant exposure during IRS examination.
Prevention Strategy
- Obtain independent, qualified appraisals from credentialed professionals
- Document the valuation methodology thoroughly
- Ensure consistent valuations across all transaction documents
- Maintain supporting documentation for any special valuations or discounts
- Address any post-sale price adjustments with proper amendments and supporting rationales
- Consider second opinions for high-value or complex assets
Mistake #8: Security and Collateralization Problems
Issues with note security arrangements frequently create DST implementation mistakes:
The Mistake
- Improperly secured installment notes
- Cross-collateralization problems with other loans
- Pledge arrangements that trigger constructive receipt
- Security interests that effectively return control to the seller
- Inadequate documentation of security arrangements
Why It Matters
The security for the installment note must balance the seller’s legitimate interest in securing payment with maintaining proper separation between seller and trust assets. Improper security arrangements can trigger immediate taxation or undermine the trust’s independence. This DST implementation mistake requires careful navigation of complex tax regulations.
Prevention Strategy
- Structure security interests that protect the seller without creating constructive receipt
- Document all security arrangements thoroughly
- Avoid arrangements where the seller effectively controls the secured assets
- Consider third-party guarantees where appropriate
- Have security arrangements reviewed by specialized tax counsel
- Monitor regulatory changes affecting pledged securities
- Implement proper perfection of security interests
Mistake #9: Insufficient Professional Guidance
Perhaps the most fundamental DST implementation mistake is inadequate expert guidance:
The Mistake
- Using professionals without DST-specific expertise
- Relying on a single advisor rather than a coordinated team
- Failure to involve tax counsel early in the process
- Selecting advisors based on cost rather than expertise
- Not obtaining proper tax opinions or guidance
Why It Matters
DSTs are sophisticated tax planning structures that require specialized knowledge across legal, tax, financial, and administrative disciplines. Generic advice or piecemeal guidance often misses critical nuances, creating substantial compliance risks. This DST implementation mistake underlies many of the other errors discussed.
Prevention Strategy
- Assemble a coordinated professional team with DST-specific experience
- Include specialized tax counsel from the earliest planning stages
- Obtain appropriate tax opinions for your specific situation
- Prioritize expertise over cost when selecting advisors
- Ensure all advisors communicate effectively with each other
- Consider a quarterback advisor to coordinate the team
- Budget adequately for professional guidance as a necessary implementation cost
Preventative Strategy Framework
Beyond addressing specific DST implementation mistakes, consider this comprehensive prevention framework:
1. Education First
Before proceeding with a DST, thoroughly understand:
- The legal foundation for installment sale treatment
- Key tax court cases defining boundaries
- IRS guidance and potential areas of scrutiny
- Legitimate business purposes beyond tax deferral
2. Deliberate Planning Timeline
Create a structured implementation schedule:
- Initial education and consultation phase
- DST structure design with professional guidance
- Trust establishment and asset transfer
- Careful marketing or buyer negotiation phase
- Closing and post-closing compliance
3. Documentation Protocol
Implement a systematic documentation approach:
- Comprehensive document checklist
- Consistent terminology across all documents
- Clear statement of business purpose
- Contemporaneous documentation of decisions
- Secure, organized record-keeping system
4. Ongoing Compliance System
Establish structures for long-term success:
- Regular trust administration reviews
- Periodic professional reassessment
- Systematic performance monitoring
- Documentation of ongoing decisions
- Adaptation to tax law changes
This framework helps prevent DST implementation mistakes by creating a systematic approach rather than addressing issues in isolation.
Case Study: DST Implementation Done Right
To illustrate proper implementation without these common DST implementation mistakes, consider this case study:
Background
- Business owner selling manufacturing company valued at $12 million
- $9 million potential capital gain
- Business owner age 62, seeking retirement income
Proper Implementation Steps
1. Early Planning (6+ months before intended sale)
- Assembled advisory team with DST expertise
- Documented non-tax business purposes (retirement transition, investment diversification)
- Created comprehensive implementation timeline
2. Trust Establishment and Transfer
- Established DST with independent institutional trustee
- Transferred business interests to trust before any binding sale agreement
- Documented arm’s-length negotiation of installment note terms
- Created detailed investment policy statement
3. Sale Negotiation and Closing
- Trustee independently negotiated with potential buyers
- Maintained clear communication boundaries between seller and trustee
- Obtained independent business valuation from credentialed appraiser
- Properly documented all aspects of the sales process
4. Post-Sale Administration
- Implemented diversified investment strategy aligned with payment obligations
- Established systematic distribution process
- Created regular review procedures for investment performance
- Maintained meticulous ongoing documentation
5. Results
- Successful deferral of $9 million capital gain
- Structured income stream for retirement
- Diversified investment portfolio versus concentrated business risk
- Substantial estate planning advantages
This case illustrates how avoiding DST implementation mistakes requires a comprehensive, systematic approach with proper professional guidance.
FAQs: Avoiding DST Implementation Mistakes
How long before a potential sale should DST planning begin?
Ideally, begin DST planning at least 3-6 months before any potential sale. This provides adequate time to establish the trust, transfer assets, and document independence before entering binding negotiations. Last-minute implementation is one of the most common DST implementation mistakes.
Can I serve as my own trustee to save on fees?
No. Self-trusteeship fundamentally undermines the independence required for a valid DST and is a critical DST implementation mistake. The trust must be genuinely independent with a trustee who exercises real discretion and control over trust assets.
What documentation is absolutely essential for a proper DST?
Essential documentation includes the trust agreement, asset transfer documents, installment sale contract, security agreements, and investment policy statement. Each document must be properly executed in the correct sequence. Inadequate or improper documentation ranks among the most serious DST implementation mistakes.
How does the IRS typically identify problems with DSTs?
The IRS may identify potential DST implementation mistakes through various means, including:
- Inconsistencies between reported transactions and documentation
- Audits triggered by large asset sales
- Examination of related entities or returns
- Information from third parties (buyers, financial institutions)
- Patterns suggesting pre-arranged sales
- Relationship analysis between parties
What happens if the IRS successfully challenges a DST structure?
If the IRS successfully challenges a DST due to significant DST implementation mistakes, consequences typically include:
- Immediate recognition of the entire capital gain
- Interest on underpaid taxes from the original sale date
- Potential penalties for underpayment
- Additional professional fees for defending the arrangement
- Possible implications for other tax and estate planning structures
Avoiding DST implementation mistakes requires careful planning, proper sequencing, thorough documentation, and expert guidance. While the potential tax benefits of a DST are substantial, they depend entirely on proper implementation and ongoing administration. By understanding these common pitfalls and implementing preventative strategies, you can maximize the likelihood of a successful, defensible DST structure.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Always consult with qualified professionals regarding your specific circumstances.
Additional Resources
